The No. 1 Mistake When Choosing Your Medicare Plan
Updated October 2026. We no longer sell Medicare Advantage plans, but this advice still matters to anyone choosing between Medicare Advantage and a Medicare Supplement.
A Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plan works alongside Original Medicare to help pay your share of costs, like coinsurance and deductibles, for a monthly premium. Unlike Medicare Advantage, it doesn’t use a network, so you can see any provider nationwide who accepts Medicare.
| Plan type | Standardized (Plans A–N), supplements Original Medicare |
| Who it's for | People who want nationwide provider access and predictable costs, and don't mind a higher premium |
| Typical monthly premium | Varies by plan letter, carrier, and age, higher than Medicare Advantage |
| Drug coverage included | No, pair with a separate Part D plan |
| Provider network | None, any provider that accepts Medicare |
| Best time to enroll | Medigap Open Enrollment Period, 6 months starting at 65 + Part B |
| Underwriting | Guaranteed issue in your open enrollment window; medically underwritten outside it |
| Carriers we work with | Aetna, Cigna HealthSpring, Mutual of Omaha, Physicians Mutual, United American, Wellabe (Medico) and WPS |
See the range of Medicare Supplement rates filed with the State of Florida for your ZIP code. No name, phone or email needed.
A Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plan is private insurance that works alongside Original Medicare to help pay your share of costs, like copayments, coinsurance, and deductibles. Unlike Medicare Advantage, a Medigap plan doesn’t replace Original Medicare or use a network, so you can see any provider nationwide who accepts Medicare.

Original Medicare (Parts A and B) is the primary payer. It covers most of a hospital stay or doctor visit, then leaves you with the remainder: the Part A hospital deductible, the 20% Part B coinsurance, and copays. A Medigap plan is the second payer. When a claim comes in, Medicare pays its share first and your Medigap company pays its share of what’s left, usually automatically, without you filing anything. Depending on the plan letter, some Medigap plans also cover emergency care when you travel outside the U.S. Medigap does not cover long-term care, routine dental, vision, hearing aids or prescriptions.
In practice, for someone in Fort Myers, that means a hospital stay at Gulf Coast Medical Center or a specialist visit in Naples works the same way it would anywhere else in the country: Medicare pays first, your plan pays second, and you don’t need a referral or a network directory.
With a Medigap plan, you can see any doctor, hospital or specialist in the U.S. who accepts Medicare, and that includes the large health systems right here at home. In Lee County, that means Lee Health’s hospitals: Lee Memorial Hospital, HealthPark Medical Center and Gulf Coast Medical Center in Fort Myers, and Cape Coral Hospital. In Collier County, it means NCH Baker Hospital Downtown and NCH North Naples Hospital. In Charlotte County, it means AdventHealth Port Charlotte and HCA Florida Fawcett Hospital.
Because there’s no network, you choose providers by reputation and convenience. A Bonita Springs or Estero resident can see a cardiologist in Naples one month and an orthopedic surgeon in Fort Myers the next, with no referral and no question of whether the doctor is “in plan.” The same is true for the many clients who split the year between Southwest Florida and a home up north: the plan covers Medicare-approved care in both places. Before you book with a new doctor, it’s still worth asking one question: “Do you accept Medicare assignment?” I’m happy to walk you through what that answer means for you.
Living in Southwest Florida means a lot of things: beautiful winters, active retirement communities, and a rhythm that often includes splitting the year between here and a home up north. Medigap is built for that lifestyle. Because there’s no network, you can see your primary care doctor in Fort Myers all winter, then visit your longtime specialist in Michigan or Ohio during the summer, and your plan pays the same way both places. That continuity matters when you’re managing a chronic condition or just want the peace of mind of keeping the same doctors.
We also know that healthcare here is concentrated in a few large systems. Lee Health’s hospitals, from Gulf Coast Medical Center to Cape Coral Hospital, all accept Medicare assignment. So do NCH in Naples and the HCA and AdventHealth facilities in Charlotte County. With a Medigap plan, you choose the facility and the physician based on reputation and convenience, not a network directory. For the many clients who live in gated communities like Pelican Preserve, Heritage Palms, or Bonita Bay, that means you can schedule a specialist visit at HealthPark Medical Center without a referral and without worrying about surprise bills.
And yes, hurricane season is real. If you evacuate to Orlando, Atlanta, or anywhere else, your coverage travels with you. Keep your red-white-and-blue Medicare card and your Medigap card in your go-bag, and you can be seen by any provider who accepts Medicare. That’s a level of flexibility that gives our clients genuine confidence, whether they’re here year-round or just for the sunny months.
Every Medigap plan with the same letter has the same benefits, no matter which company sells it. A Plan G from one carrier pays exactly what a Plan G from another carrier pays. Plans are labeled A, B, C, D, F, G, K, L, M and N, plus a high-deductible version of Plan G. Plans C and F can only be bought by people who were eligible for Medicare before January 1, 2020; everyone newer to Medicare chooses from the rest, and most choose Plan G or Plan N.
In Florida, the Office of Insurance Regulation approves Medigap policy forms and reviews every rate filing, and those filed rates are public. That’s where the figures in the estimator above come from. The Florida Department of Financial Services licenses agents (my license is A160316) and handles consumer complaints. Florida law also requires companies that sell Medigap here to offer it to people under 65 who have Medicare because of a disability or end-stage renal disease, during a six-month window after they enroll in Part B. Not every state requires that.
Because the benefits are identical, price is the main difference between companies, and the spread is wide. Here’s what the rates on file with the state look like for Fort Myers and the rest of Lee County. To see figures for your own ZIP code and age, use the premium estimator above.
| Non-tobacco | Plan G median | Plan G range | Plan N median | Plan N range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Woman, 65 | $246 | $201–$344 | $187 | $142–$318 |
| Man, 65 | $273 | $217–$380 | $207 | $163–$351 |
| Woman, 70 | $276 | $211–$395 | $204 | $162–$365 |
| Man, 70 | $308 | $234–$436 | $235 | $181–$403 |
| Woman, 75 | $308 | $236–$453 | $236 | $186–$419 |
| Man, 75 | $342 | $258–$501 | $262 | $210–$463 |
Monthly premiums. Median and range of the sample rates on file with the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation for Lee County ZIP codes, for policies effective January 1, 2027, divided by 12 and rounded. Collier and Charlotte County rates on file are nearly identical. Not a quote; policy fees and household discounts are not included.
Your best window is your Medigap Open Enrollment Period: six months that start the first month you’re both 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. During those six months, a company can’t turn you down or charge you more because of your health. After it ends, most changes require answering health questions, and a company can decline you.
One point that confuses a lot of people here: the October 15 to December 7 Medicare enrollment period you see advertised every fall on Southwest Florida TV is for Medicare Advantage and Part D drug plans. It is not a Medigap enrollment window. You can apply for a Medigap plan any time of year; what matters is whether you’re still in your six-month window or have a guaranteed-issue right. If you’re turning 65 in Fort Myers, Cape Coral or Naples, plan to start comparing about three months before your Part B start date.
If you’d also like an unbiased second opinion, Florida’s free SHINE program offers Medicare counseling through the Area Agency on Aging for Southwest Florida, (239) 652-6900.
A Medigap plan generally costs more per month than Medicare Advantage, but offers more predictable out-of-pocket costs and nationwide provider access with no referrals needed. Medicare Advantage plans often have lower or $0 premiums and extra benefits, but use a provider network, which matters if you spend part of the year outside Southwest Florida. Many clients pair their Medigap plan with a stand-alone Part D prescription drug plan, since Medigap doesn’t include drug coverage. We sell Medicare Supplements, not Medicare Advantage or Part D plans; you can compare and enroll in those at Medicare.gov.
Since Medigap doesn’t cover everything, some clients also add a hospital indemnity plan for extra cash protection during a hospital stay. And if you’re not yet 65, see our individual health insurance page to bridge the gap until Medicare eligibility.
Reach out as you’re approaching 65, during your six-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period, when you move to Southwest Florida, or any time your current premium feels out of line with what other carriers charge for the same plan.
Talk with Charles “Chuck” Lunsford, a Florida-licensed agent since 1994. No cost, no obligation.

Charles “Chuck” LunsfordOwner and licensed Life & Health agent, Fort Myers
I’ve been a Florida-licensed agent since 1994, and for more than 30 years I’ve helped people across Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties choose coverage that fits their health and their budget. For Medicare, Medicare Supplements are my focus. I don’t sell Medicare Advantage, so my advice on which Medigap plan and which company makes sense isn’t pulled in another direction.
You work with me directly, by phone, text or email, from the first comparison through the years after you enroll. When rates go up, I’m the one who tells you whether it’s time to shop again.
A Local Fort Myers Agency That Knows Your Healthcare Landscape
We’ve lived and worked in Southwest Florida since 1994, so we know the local healthcare landscape, from Lee Health’s Gulf Coast Medical Center and HealthPark Medical Center to NCH in Naples and the region’s specialists. That local knowledge matters. For example, Lee Health is leaving UnitedHealthcare’s Medicare Advantage plans on January 1, 2027, while Medigap plans, which work with any provider who accepts Medicare, aren’t affected. You get plan recommendations that reflect real-world access to the doctors and facilities you already trust, not a generic national sales pitch.
Independent Advice From a Licensed Professional, Not a Captive Call Center
As an independent agency, I’m not tied to any single insurance carrier. I hold Florida Life & Health License A160316 (NPN 553216) and have been actively licensed since 1994. That means I compare Medigap plans from multiple insurers to find you the best combination of premium stability and coverage, saving you hours of confusing research.
Straightforward Rate Transparency With No Pressure
I’ll show you the actual rate ranges filed with the State of Florida for your ZIP code, age, and plan letter. My online quoting tool gives you a clear estimate without requiring a phone number or email, so you can compare Plan G, Plan N, and High-Deductible G at your own pace. No hidden fees, no bait-and-switch.
A Personalized, One-on-One Consultation That Speaks Your Language
You’ll work directly with me, not a rotating team of agents. I take the time to explain how Medigap works with Original Medicare, what it means for your appointments at Lee Health, NCH or any other provider who accepts Medicare, and how to pair a standalone Part D plan for prescriptions. It’s a relaxed, educational conversation where every question is welcome.
A Reputation Built on Long-Term Client Relationships
Most of our new clients come from referrals by existing ones, a reflection of the trust we’ve earned over three decades, and we’re proud to serve seniors across Lee, Collier, and Charlotte counties with the same care we’d give our own family.
Medigap generally doesn’t cover long-term care (like nursing home care), vision or dental services, hearing aids, eyeglasses, or private-duty nursing.
No. Medigap only works alongside Original Medicare. If you switch to a Medicare Advantage plan, you generally can’t use a Medigap policy, and most insurers won’t sell you one while you’re enrolled in Medicare Advantage.
No. While the benefits of each standardized plan letter (like Plan G) are identical across insurance companies, premiums for the exact same plan can vary significantly between carriers, and may increase as you get older. It’s worth comparing carriers even for the same plan letter.
Yes, but outside your initial Medigap Open Enrollment Period or certain guaranteed-issue situations, the insurance company can medically underwrite you, meaning they can ask health questions and potentially deny coverage or charge more.
Plan G covers nearly all of your out-of-pocket costs after the Part B deductible, for a higher premium. Plan N has a lower premium but requires small copays for some doctor and ER visits, and you may be responsible for any excess charges a provider adds. We can review which trade-off makes sense for your budget and how often you see providers.
Usually yes, month to month, but it offers broader provider access and more predictable out-of-pocket costs.
Yes, Medigap only supplements Original Medicare, so you need to keep Part A and Part B.
Florida follows the federal standardized plans, but a few state rules matter. The Florida Office of Insurance Regulation approves every Medigap policy and rate filing, so the rates you’re quoted are on file with the state. Companies that sell Medigap in Florida must also offer it to people under 65 who have Medicare because of a disability or end-stage renal disease, during the six months after they enroll in Part B. And Florida doesn’t ban Part B excess charges, which matters if you’re weighing Plan N. Federal guaranteed-issue rights, such as when your employer coverage ends or your Medigap company goes out of business, apply here too.
Nationally, Plan G is now the most popular Medigap plan, with about 6.3 million members in 2025 according to industry analyst Mark Farrah Associates. It covers everything Original Medicare leaves except the Part B deductible, so costs are predictable. Plan N is the common alternative for people who want a lower premium and don’t mind small copays. You can compare the median rates for both in your ZIP code with the estimator on this page.
Yes. Medigap plans are guaranteed renewable and go with you anywhere in the U.S. as long as you keep paying the premium. Your premium will be reset to the rates for your new location, so it’s worth comparing again after a move. Switching to a different company after you move usually means answering health questions.
It doesn’t. If you evacuate to Orlando, Atlanta or anywhere else, you can be seen by any provider who accepts Medicare, and your plan pays the same way it does at home. Keep your red-white-and-blue Medicare card and your Medigap card in your evacuation bag. (Medicare Advantage plans also have special rules during a declared disaster that let members use out-of-network facilities at in-network cost.)
Yes, and many of my clients do exactly that. Medigap works well for seasonal residents because it has no network: you can see your doctors in Fort Myers in the winter and your doctors back home in the summer with the same coverage. If you have a guaranteed-issue right or are still in your open enrollment window, we’ll compare companies based on the address where you’ll be insured.
Updated October 2026. We no longer sell Medicare Advantage plans, but this advice still matters to anyone choosing between Medicare Advantage and a Medicare Supplement.

Many veterans ask whether they need Medicare if they already have VA health care. You aren’t required to sign up, but for most veterans enrolling
Tell us what you’re looking for and the best time to reach you. We usually call back within one business day.
Prefer to talk now? Call (239) 633-4392.